HKTDC Hong Kong Means Business

Hong Kong Means Business Hong Kong Means Business

Search form

Languages

  • EN
  • 繁
  • 简
SUBSCRIBE
  • EVENTS
  • MY FEED
  • CONTACT HKTDC
  • ABOUT HKTDC
  • hktdc.com

Section Menu

  • multimedia
  • market spotlight
  • first person
  • Venture Hong Kong
  • heads-up
  • inside china
  • life & style
  • hktdc research

Search form

Languages

  • EN
  • 繁
  • 简
SUBSCRIBE
Hong Kong Means Business

Section Menu

  • multimedia
  • market spotlight
  • first person
  • Venture Hong Kong
  • heads-up
  • inside china
  • life & style
  • hktdc research
hktdc research
SAVE FOR LATER
SHARE / SEND

EU’s General Court Rules Against Current Energy Labelling of Vacuum Cleaners

15 November 2018

It is reported that on 8 November 2018, the EU’s General Court, located in Luxembourg, repealed the EU’s Energy Labelling Regulation for vacuum cleaners. This follows a heated and long-standing dispute between the European Commission and Dyson over the EU’s energy labelling requirements.

Hong Kong’s household electronics suppliers will very likely already be aware that the EU’s framework energy labelling law ranks home and professional appliances by giving them energy efficiency labels. The fundamental reasoning behind the law is that consumers should be made aware of their products’ energy consumption, which in turn might impact their purchasing choices by avoiding the most energy-wasteful products, while also saving money on household electricity bills.

Dyson, however, argued that the testing process within the laboratory, which is intended to determine the efficiency and in turn the grading of vacuum cleaners, is faulty.

Dyson lodged its complaints back in 2013, contending that the rules are flawed, as they lead to the testing of vacuum cleaners with empty dust bags. However, in such a scenario, a machine can be given a higher efficiency rating, even though such a result does not reflect real-life conditions. The company held that products have to be tested in real-world conditions because vacuum cleaners using bags and filters can become clogged; this, in turn, leads in some cases to a loss of suction power. Therefore, a consumer would be fooled into thinking that he is buying an A-rated product, while in reality it could drop to G-grade efficiency when used in the home.

The problem, according to Dyson, is that such rules discriminate against its own products: Dyson only produces bagless vacuum cleaners. The testing procedure, even though authorised, could be considered by some to be reminiscent of the Dieselgate scandal, i.e., the Volkswagen emissions scandal, where Volkswagen cars had a “defeat device” - or software - in diesel engines that could detect when they were being tested, changing the performance accordingly to improve results.

A spokesperson for Dyson has, indeed, commented that “in these days of Dieselgate, it is essential consumers can trust what manufacturers say about their products. But the Commission endorsed a measure that allowed Dyson’s competitors to game the system”.

The spokesperson added that the Regulation on energy labelling “benefited traditional, predominantly German, manufacturers who lobbied senior Commission officials. Some manufacturers have actively exploited the regulation by using low motor power when in the test state, but then using technology to increase motor power automatically when the machine fills with dust – thus appearing more efficient”.

Pursuant to the General Court’s ruling, campaigners are concerned that eliminating the relevant Regulation completely would be harmful for the consumer and the environment. It is thought that the Regulation (despite any flaws it may have) does deliver valuable benefits to consumers and the economy.

Chris Spiliotopoulos, a policy offer at ECOS (a European environmental organisation), which is a campaigner for more efficient products, has commented that “the Ecodesign and Energy Labelling Regulations for vacuum cleaners are expected to save 19 terawatt hours (TWh) per year by 2020, equivalent to the electricity produced by 26 medium size coal power plants.”

Nonetheless, the same spokesperson highlighted that test methods ought to better reflect the way in which products – and consumers – behave in reality. “Policy-makers need to fix this imminently and harmonise a test method which takes into account real-life considerations”.

The European Environmental Bureau’s Stephane Arditi has also claimed that energy labelling is extremely necessary – along with ecodesign requirements – to produce more resource- and energy-efficient electronic products. These, in turn, would assist in achieving the EU’s climate targets. He reasoned that “Perhaps this could be an opportunity to improve the labels and the way we conduct lab tests. But any amendments to the regulation must be approved as quickly as possible to ensure people can benefit from the projected savings”.

Given that the court has only just ruled on annulling the energy labelling of vacuum cleaners, it is still unclear as to what happens next. The European Commission may be considering whether or not to appeal the General Court’s ruling. Indeed, it has been reported that the label will continue in force for a period of time so as to allow time for appeal. BSH Hausgeraete, the group which stemmed from a joint venture between Robert Bosch GmbH and Siemens AG, has stated that it would “thoroughly analyse the decision and what this will mean for manufacturers of vacuum cleaners”.

BACK TO TOP ^
CONTENT PROVIDED BY
    Topics:
  • Electronics & Electrical Appliances,
  • United Kingdom,
  • EU,
  • Western Europe,
  • energy consumption standard,
  • energy efficiency,
  • green products,
  • policies & regulations
POST A COMMENT
  • Electronics & Electrical Appliances
  • United Kingdom
  • EU
  • Western Europe
Home

Article Topics

ARTICLE TOPICS

ELECTRONICS...24646
UNITED KINGDOM36245
EU37804
WESTERN EUROPE36222
ENERGY CONSUMPTION...75006

ARTICLE TOPICS

ELECTRONICS & ELECTRICAL APPLIANCES24646
UNITED KINGDOM36245
EU37804
WESTERN EUROPE36222
ENERGY CONSUMPTION STANDARD75006
ENERGY EFFICIENCY74999
GREEN PRODUCTS75000
POLICIES & REGULATIONS72580

Social Share

FOLLOW US

GET WEEKLY UPDATES

newpaper-img

GET OUR WEEKLY EMAIL UPDATES

banner-img


I acknowledge that the above information may be used by the Hong Kong Trade Development Council (HKTDC) for incorporation in all or any of its database for direct marketing or business matching purpose (and may therefore become available to the public within and/or outside of Hong Kong for use by them), and for any other purposes as stated in the Privacy Policy Statement; I confirm that I have the consent and the authority of each individual named in this form to release their personal data for the purposes stated herein.


*For non-EU/EEA customers, please skip this box which is solely for EU/EEA customers as required by the relevant data protection law in the EU.

THANK YOU

Thank you for registering.

interest_article

YOU MAY BE INTERESTED IN

14 February 2019

UK Plans to Introduce UKCA Symbol to Replace CE Marking in Case of a “No Deal” Brexit

08 February 2019

Suppliers Required to Register in European Product Database for Energy Labelling

29 January 2019

Technical Amendments Made to Power Supply Energy Standards, Deadline for Input on Residential Furnace/Water Heater Petition Extended

25 January 2019

EU Member States Rule in Favour of Right to Repair

Related Events

RELATED EVENTS

13-16 April 2019

HKTDC Hong Kong Electronics Fair (Spring Edition) 2019

15-19 August 2019

HKTDC Home Delights Expo 2019

13-16 October 2019

electronicAsia 2019

30 October - 2 November 2019

Eco Expo Asia 2019
FIND AN EVENT

User login

  • Create new account
  • Request new password

Footer Menu

  • hktdc.com
  • ABOUT HKTDC
  • MEDIA ROOM
  • TERMS OF USE
  • PRIVACY POLICY
  • SITE MAP
  • 京ICP备09059244号

Footer Logo

Copyrights

Copyright © 2019 Hong Kong Trade Development Council. All rights reserved.

SHARE THIS STORY

EMAIL
LINKEDIN
GOOGLE+
FACEBOOK
TWITTER
WEIBO

POST A COMMENT

OR

POST A COMMENT

Don't have an account?

Create An Account

successfully added on your preferences.