HKMB Hong Kong Means Business

Hong Kong Means Business Hong Kong Means Business
  • Login / Register

Languages

  • EN
  • 繁
  • 简
  • Events
  • My Feed
  • Contact HKTDC
  • Subscribe
  • Subscribe

Section Menu

  • Market Opportunities
  • Tech & Innovation
  • Entrepreneurship
  • Sustainability
  • Creativity & Lifestyle
  • HKTDC Updates
  • Featured Topics

Languages

  • EN
  • 繁
  • 简
  • HKTDC.com |
  • About HKTDC |
  • My HKTDC |
  • Login / Register |

HKTDC.com About HKTDC My HKTDC

Login Register

Hong Kong Means Business

Section Menu

  • Market Opportunities
  • Tech & Innovation
  • Entrepreneurship
  • Sustainability
  • Creativity & Lifestyle
  • HKTDC Updates
  • Featured Topics

https://hkmb.hktdc.com/en/NTQwMjM2NjUy

hktdc research
SAVE FOR LATER
SHARE / SEND

"Scan QR Code" in WeChat and tap "..." to share.

WTO Rules Against U.S. Section 301 Tariffs

17 September 2020



A World Trade Organisation dispute settlement panel ruled on 15 September that the United States’ imposition of additional tariffs on US$234 billion worth of imports from mainland China violated U.S. obligations under WTO rules. U.S. officials decried the decision, although it will likely have no practical effect.

Following a Section 301 investigation, the Office of the U.S. Trade Representative determined that mainland China’s acts, policies and practices related to technology transfer, intellectual property, and innovation are unreasonable and discriminatory. In response, USTR imposed an additional tariff of 25 percent on 818 products from mainland China with a trade value of about US$34 billion (List 1 goods) and then an additional 10 percent tariff (later increased to 25 percent) on another 5,745 products with a trade value of about US$200 billion (List 3 goods). Most of these tariffs remain in place despite the granting of some exclusions and mainland China’s imposition of its own retaliatory tariffs.

The WTO panel agreed with mainland China that the Section 301 tariffs violated WTO rules because they (i) applied only to products originating from mainland China, in violation of the most-favoured-nation principle requiring WTO members to assess equal tariff rates on imports from other members, and (ii) exceeded the U.S.’ bound tariff rates. The panel rejected the U.S. argument that the phase 1 trade agreement it reached with mainland China earlier this year effectively resolved this dispute.

USTR Robert Lighthizer slammed the decision, which he said “confirms what the Trump Administration has been saying for four years: The WTO is completely inadequate to stop China’s harmful technology practices.” He noted that the panel “did not dispute the extensive evidence submitted by the United States of intellectual property theft by China” and asserted that the United States “must be allowed to defend itself against unfair trade practices.”

The ruling will likely have little to no immediate effect on the tariffs; among other things, a final resolution is currently precluded by the WTO Appellate Body’s inability to operate. However, it could be considered in a recently-filed federal case challenging the Section 301 tariffs on List 3 and List 4A goods that, if successful, could result in the refund of all such tariffs. Specifically, this case asserts that Congress did not empower the executive branch to transform investigations targeting specific practices by a foreign country (e.g., the mainland Chinese intellectual property policies and practices that underlie the Section 301 tariffs) into a vast, unlimited trade war. The case also argues that in promulgating List 3 and List 4A USTR failed to follow required statutory provisions, making those actions invalid under the Administrative Procedures Act.

BACK TO TOP ^
    Topics:
  • North America,
  • Mainland China,
  • USA,
  • trade dispute,
  • Section 301,
  • customs & tariffs & duties,
  • world trade organisation,
  • Dispute Settlement
  • North America
  • Mainland China
  • USA
  • North America
  • Mainland China
  • USA
  • North America
  • Mainland China
  • USA
  • North America
  • Mainland China
  • USA
  • North America
  • Mainland China
  • USA
  • North America
  • Mainland China
  • USA
  • North America
  • Mainland China
  • USA
  • North America
  • Mainland China
  • USA
  • North America
  • Mainland China
  • USA
  • North America
  • Mainland China
  • USA
  • North America
  • Mainland China
  • USA
Home

Article Topics

ARTICLE TOPICS

NORTH AMERICA36097
MAINLAND CHINA35607
USA36116
TRADE DISPUTE76304
SECTION 301130769

ARTICLE TOPICS

NORTH AMERICA36097
MAINLAND CHINA35607
USA36116
TRADE DISPUTE76304
SECTION 301130769
CUSTOMS & TARIFFS & DUTIES74631
WORLD TRADE ORGANISATION80323
DISPUTE SETTLEMENT133528
SINO-US TRADE132142

interest_article

YOU MAY BE INTERESTED IN

26 July 2022

Trade Provisions Cut from Mainland China Bill, Could See Action Later this Year

30 May 2022

Biden Eyes Changes to Mainland China Tariffs but Senators Say They Should Stay

11 March 2022

Review of Section 301 Tariffs on List 1 Goods Could Be Initiated Soon

24 January 2022

“Not There Yet” on Lifting Tariffs on Mainland China, President Biden Says

Related Events

RELATED EVENTS

11 - 15 April 2023

Style Hong Kong Pavilion at China International Consumer Products Expo, Haikou

24 May 2023

SmartHK 2023, Guangzhou

26 - 28 May 2023

Chic HK, Shenzhen

28 - 30 June 2023

22nd Shanghai International Children Baby and Maternity Products Industry Expo (CBME)
FIND AN EVENT

Social Share

FOLLOW US

GET WEEKLY UPDATES

newpaper-img

GET OUR WEEKLY EMAIL UPDATES

banner-img


I acknowledge that the above information may be used by the Hong Kong Trade Development Council (HKTDC) for incorporation in all or any of its database for direct marketing or business matching purpose (and may therefore become available to the public within and/or outside of Hong Kong for use by them), and for any other purposes as stated in the Privacy Policy Statement; I confirm that I have the consent and the authority of each individual named in this form to release their personal data for the purposes stated herein.


*For non-EU/EEA customers, please skip this box which is solely for EU/EEA customers as required by the relevant data protection law in the EU.

THANK YOU

Thank you for registering.

SHARE THIS STORY

EMAIL
LINKEDIN
WeChat
FACEBOOK
TWITTER
WHATSAPP

ID: HKTDCofficial

Don't have an account?

Create An Account

successfully added on your preferences.